Breaking News
Editorial

It’s worth debating office of state auditor

4 min read
HOPPY KERCHEVAL

The controversy surrounding State Auditor Mark Hunt and his subsequent indictment on corruption charges should have West Virginians thinking seriously about--wait for it--the office of state auditor.

That is not a subject that typically gets voters or policymakers excited, but the Hunt scandal has created an opportunity to debate two important questions:

Does West Virginia really need an auditor, and should that be an elected position?

The answer to the first question is an emphatic yes.

The state needs an office responsible for financial oversight, auditing local governments, administering certain property tax functions, processing payroll and payments, and helping detect fraud, waste, and abuse, just to name some of its responsibilities.

In short, the office performs important work.

But what happens when the auditor himself is accused of corruption, as is now the case in West Virginia? For the record, an indictment is an accusation, not a conviction. Hunt is presumed innocent, and he has denied wrongdoing.

Every state has some form of government auditing function, although the method of selecting the chief auditor varies. Some states elect their auditors, while others appoint or hire them.

You would think that someone responsible for overseeing government finances should know at least something about accounting.

The National Association of State Auditors, Comptrollers and Treasurers emphasizes the importance of professional competence. Its constitution calls for promoting standards of excellence, improving government financial management, and enhancing the financial management skills of its members.

Yet West Virginia has no specific accounting or auditing experience requirement for its state auditor. The auditor is a constitutional officer, but the Constitution does not require professional financial expertise.

That means someone who believes the number 23 mysteriously connects major historical events--yes, that is an actual conspiracy theory--could become state auditor simply by winning enough votes.

I am reminded of the 1989 impeachment proceedings involving State Treasurer A. James Manchin following massive losses in the state’s investment fund. Manchin acknowledged that he did not understand that parentheses around figures on a financial statement indicated losses.

The House of Delegates also censured then-State Auditor Glen Gainer for failing to exercise sufficient oversight of state investments. The Legislature subsequently restructured the state’s investment responsibilities.

Which brings us to the second question.

West Virginia could follow the example of states that appoint or hire their chief auditors rather than elect them. That would require amending the state constitution.

However, an appointment system comes with its own risks. A governor or legislature could choose someone whose principal qualification is being a political friend, supporter or donor.

The better approach may be to establish meaningful professional qualifications for the office, regardless of whether the auditor is elected or appointed.

Oklahoma, for example, elects its state auditor and inspector but requires candidates to have at least three years of experience as an expert accountant.

Establishing similar requirements in West Virginia could raise constitutional questions. Article IV, Section 5 provides that, beyond the prescribed oath to support the Constitution, no other oath, declaration or test shall be required as a qualification.

A professional qualifications requirement would therefore need careful legal review and might require a constitutional amendment.

Side note: This makes me wonder why our founders went out of their way to protect our right to elect any dunderhead we please.

Remember 2012, when Texas prison inmate Keith Judd received 41 percent of the vote against incumbent President Barack Obama in West Virginia’s Democratic presidential primary?

But I digress.

The state auditor should understand government finance, possess the professional skills necessary to oversee public funds and carry out the office’s responsibilities without fear or favor. The allegations against Hunt raise questions more about ethics than competence. But the two qualities are equally essential. Taxpayers deserve an auditor who not only knows what he is doing, but can also be trusted to do what is right.

The charges against Hunt raise troubling questions about the integrity of an office entrusted with protecting taxpayer dollars. Whether those allegations are proven will be determined through the legal process.

Meanwhile, West Virginia has an opportunity to consider whether its system for choosing a state auditor provides taxpayers with the accountability and professional competence they deserve.

It is a debate worth having.

Starting at /week.