Fayette County residents voice concerns at MARL hearing
Trending
Fayette County residents concerned about the route of a proposed high-power electric line running near or through their properties testified for nearly three hours Wednesday night at a Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission hearing in Point Marion on NextEra's application to operate as a public utility in the state.
NextEra's MidAtlantic Resiliency Link project would include a 107.5-mile, 500-kilovolt transmission line extending from Greene County to Frederick County, Va., as well as a new 500/138 kilovolt substation in Virginia.
The proposed route would start in Dunkard Township in Greene County and end near Gore, Va. It would cover about four miles in Greene County and seven in Fayette.
The PUC has stayed NextEra's siting application for that line until it resolves the public utility application.
Afternoon and evening hearings were held in Mount Morris Tuesday, followed by the hearings in Point Marion Wednesday.
Wednesday night's hearing included testimony from several area residents, as well as statements from several parties, including NextEra, Pennsylvania's Office of Consumer Advocate and state Rep. Charity Grimm Krupa, who also testified.
The proposed route cuts through properties owned by some of Wednesday's attendees.
Many worried about what would happen if NextEra becomes a public utility, which gives it power to condemn private property through eminent domain.
Susan Zuchowsky of Smithfield said she had planned to pass her 20 acres of farmland down to her heirs.
If the company is going to seize her property, she said, she wanted an equivalent amount of land somewhere else where she could build without having to be exposed to the physical, mental or environmental impacts.
"Why can’t you build up against the existing power line?" she said. "They already have a maintenance area. They’re not touching their towers. They won’t infringe on them, but they’ll take our ground, destroy our farmland, destroy our views, destroy our health, take away our legacy, our heritage."
Springhill Township resident Dinah Redpath said she had been approached repeatedly in person and over the phone by a land agent for NextEra about selling property to put a tower in her horse pasture. Each time she had said no to the agent, who she described as "condescending and disrespectful."
Redpath was worried about the way the tower would impose on the views from her porch. And she was also concerned about what it would do to the value of her home; her neighbor's asking price had already dropped $50,000, she said.
"We have a really great, beautiful place," she said. "We love to share with each other, with family, with friends, but I do not want to share it with NextEra. They can figure something else out."
To become a public utility, state code requires the company to demonstrate that granting the certificate is "necessary or proper for the service, accommodation, convenience, or safety of the public."
Many of the speakers questioned whether the transmission line would deliver benefits to customers locally. The cost of the project has risen from an estimated $441 million four years ago to $960 million now.
"Our seniors, our working families, our veterans, our small businesses cannot continue absorbing increases without asking some very serious questions: Who is benefiting from this project? Who is paying for it, or will pay for it? And why should Pennsylvania residents bear additional costs for a project that has not demonstrated a proportionate direct benefit to Pennsylvania consumers?" Grimm Krupa said.
Kaitlin McCormick, senior director of development at NextEra, said after the meeting the MARL line could benefit local residents through its connection to the 502 Junction in Greene County, comparing it to a highway and interchange.
"That’s a substation that already has connection to other voltage lines in the area, and provides an opportunity for power to come on and off the Mid-Atlantic Resiliency Link, and as part of that, provides the opportunity for power to flow into the lower voltage system to come into Pennsylvania to come into West Virginia and move in both directions," she said.
McCormick said she planned to talk with NextEra's land team to follow up on the residents’ concerns. The company's goal is to have 100% voluntary participation for land easements while working with owners to minimize impacts, McCormick said.
"Our core values are that we do the right thing and we treat people with respect," she said. "And part of that is what we bring into all our interactions and to make sure that we’re professional, polite, and we’re respecting the feedback that we get from those individuals as it comes."
Residents may get another chance to weigh in.
Grimm Krupa requested a third hearing after several speakers at the Mount Morris meetings were dominated by people who talked about the lack of public notice.
After hearing from arguments on both sides Wednesday, PUC administrative judges said they would recommend another hearing.
Judges said the new virtual meeting would likely be accessed by telephone and online through some means such as Microsoft Teams. It is tentatively scheduled for Dec. 16.
People can also follow the progress of the cases at puc.pa.gov by searching for case number A-2026-3060921 (the public utility request) and A-2026-3060856 (the siting permit).