Breaking News
Columns/Opinion

Bird In Hand challenges viewers to deeper thinking

By 4byline4 Submitted to The Dominion Post 7 min read
ALISE CHAFFINS

One of the first things we see in Melody C. Rocher's "Bird in Hand" is a drunk woman in a bloodied wedding gown. After we learn that she was attending a Halloween party, the young man she's with offers a half-hearted proposal, which she accepts in an equally lackluster manner. This opening does an excellent job of introducing us to our main character, a biracial woman in search of her father, and to some degree, herself. The film is available on VOD.

After Bird (Alisha Wainwright) accepts this proposal, she immediately leaves to visit her mother, Carlotta (Christine Lahti), under the auspices of searching for a venue for her wedding. While she does visit some plantations as potential spaces to hold the ceremony, her primary goal seems to be trying to locate the father she never knew. Everything is further complicated when she forms a strained bond with her mother's neighbors, Leigh (Annabelle Dexter-Jones) and Dennis (James Le Gros), an unhappy couple trying to update the narrative about the plantation that they have purchased.

"Bird in Hand" puts a lot into its 90-minute runtime. While there is no question that nearly everything here rings authentic, it sometimes feels overstuffed in a way that doesn't allow the more compelling aspects of the film to blossom as much as they could have. Still, when the story is in the zone, it has a level of poignancy that is sure to grab your attention and make you consider the way that race and parenting can affect other aspects of your life.

The performances are a bit of a mixed bag here. I found Le Gros and Dexter-Jones to be a bit over the top in ways that were simply distracting. It's not awful, but there's little subtlety in their scenes, and I found them harder to watch. That said, Lahti is fantastic. She brings a lot to a character who can be really difficult to like at times, and her scenes with Wainwright are all beautifully played out. Wainwright is fantastic in her own right. If some performances feel like a bludgeon, hers is delicate and thoughtful. When we find ourselves frustrated with some of the choices that Bird makes, we understand them because of the strength of her acting.

One aspect of "Bird in Hand" that works in its favor is the way that it wrestles with the plantation wedding business. Filmed in Virginia at an actual plantation, the film does a great job of showing how people can want to honor their heritage, but how that can come at the expense of others. Just because something is a beautiful location doesn't erase the harm that may have occurred there in the past.

That theme is what runs through the entirety of this movie. Beautiful things built on or resulting in someone else's pain. "Bird in Hand" asks us to look beyond simple answers and to instead find something deeper. To look with empathy and honesty in equal measure at the world we live in and the one that we create.

Rating: 3.5/5

Making the film "Bird in Hand" was very personal for writer and director Melody C. Rocher. The main character, Bird, shares a lot of her experiences. "I wanted to write this film as a writing exercise, which is what it started as. It was a chance for me to be just vulnerable and to challenge myself as a craftsperson. This specific story came out of things I was dealing with in my upbringing and with my life. Things I really wanted to press myself on, process and grow through, so I put it into the script."

When we asked Melody about the title of the film, she told us, "Bird in Hand was a play on Bird's hand in marriage. But one of my bigger, more grounding philosophies going into writing this was that I wanted the characters to have a lot of trouble challenging themselves to do what’s harder, what’s a little bit out of reach. So, kind of like taking the bird in the hand versus two in the bush, which I know is not quite the meaning of the idiom, but for me, it made a lot of sense. It was like they kept making the easier decisions and taking the low-hanging fruit instead of challenging themselves to grow."

One thing that "Bird in Hand" does is to explore the way that plantations are still used as wedding venues. Rocher filmed at a plantation and shared some of the challenges that came with that decision. "Working at a plantation had its own challenges for every actor and every team member. We actually had counselors there the first day to help people acclimate to the space because it’s kind of a challenging environment to go to work, and so that was part of it."

Bird spends much of the movie with her mother, and the two have a difficult relationship: sometimes very loving and other times very confrontational. We asked about that, and Rocher told us, "I think Alicia (Wainwright) put it best, talking about Bird and Carlotta, when she said that a lot of single parents end up finding themselves in a codependent relationship with their child. That is the case with Bird and Carlotta. They are super codependent, even though that doesn’t mean they necessarily get along or even know how to get along. They need each other. They need each other’s approval, affection, company. They’re a big deal to each other, but they are so challenged to make a harder decision. To push yourself to be honest and loving without it being some sort of transactional exchange or meaning something more."

A large part of the film follows Bird as she looks for her biological father, and we see how that need has fueled some negative behavior in her. Speaking about that, Rocher said, "I think Bird’s character is very much in that place where she needs to define herself as an adult person, which sounds so simple, but it’s not. She’s had this arrested development, and the film opens with someone saying, 'Can you be my wife? Like, you’re a mess, and I love you and accept you, but do you want to be my wife?' And she’s someone who clearly isn’t capable of just taking a step into maturity and accountability. She suspects that this missing person in her life is the one to blame, and that it is his doing to her, rather than her doing to herself in reaction to his absence."

"Bird in Hand" is Rocher's first feature film, and we asked her what she learned from this project. "There are certain things that my voice and my vision will be able to produce, and I’m gonna just keep leaning into those things; I’m not going to try to be a filmmaker that I’m not. You watch other people’s work sometimes, and you’re just like, 'God, I wish I could have made that.' But I think after this, I’m going to make what I can make, and I’m going to do it as best I can, and I’m going to commit to it."

Starting at /week.