Breaking News
Business

Secret Sandwich Society brings West Virginia roots to Morgantown

2 min read

MORGANTOWN – A good sandwich shop can become more than a place to grab lunch. It can become a gathering spot, a neighborhood staple and another piece of what makes a community unique.

Secret Sandwich Society is building that kind of connection in Morgantown.

The West Virginia-based restaurant recently opened its newest location at Suncrest Towne Centre, bringing a familiar name to a new part of the state and introducing Morgantown residents to a menu built around creative sandwiches, burgers and house-made ingredients.

The business has roots in Fayetteville, where Secret Sandwich Society first opened in 2010. What started as a small restaurant in the New River Gorge region eventually developed a following among locals and visitors alike. Its original location was destroyed by a fire in November 2020 before reopening in September 2023 after a lengthy rebuilding process.

The restaurant has continued to grow since then, and the Morgantown location represents another opportunity to expand its reach while maintaining its West Virginia roots.

For Morgantown, the addition brings another established West Virginia business into a community that continues to welcome new restaurants and small businesses. It also gives Secret Sandwich Society an opportunity to connect with a different customer base, including residents, students and visitors who may not have made the trip to Fayetteville.

The menu is part of what makes the restaurant stand out. Sandwiches carry names such as the Kennedy, Roosevelt and Lady Bird, with combinations that go beyond the traditional deli counter. The Kennedy features slow-roasted pork shoulder, ham, Swiss cheese, house pickles and roasted garlic mayonnaise, while the Roosevelt pairs beef with bacon, white cheddar and horseradish mayonnaise.

There are also burgers, salads and starters, including the popular pimento cheese fries and house-made dips.

That variety gives customers plenty of options, but the restaurant’s identity goes beyond its food.

For Secret Sandwich Society, opening in Morgantown is another step in the growth of a business that began in West Virginia. For Morgantown, it is another addition to an already diverse local restaurant scene.

The name might suggest keeping things under wraps, but with another West Virginia community now part of the society, the secret is getting harder to keep.

Starting at /week.