Breaking News
Local Government

Planning commission: City should push back on ADU law

By BEN CONLEY 4 min read

MORGANTOWN - As just one component of an overall effort to increase housing options, staff and elected officials with the city of Morgantown spent months crafting legislation that would expand opportunities for accessory dwelling units within the city.

An accessory dwelling unit (ADU) is a self-contained and independently accessed living unit on the same parcel as a single-family dwelling of greater square footage. They can be internal to the existing home, built additions to the existing home, or standalone structures.

Currently, ADUs are only allowable in the city's Wiles Hill Overlay District, but the legislation in process would have made such units permissible in residential districts with owner-occupied homes. Further, the changes would have relaxed some restrictions tied to setbacks and height restrictions.

But where the city was looking to carve ADUs into city code with a scalpel, the West Virginia Legislature brought a cleaver.

Senate Bill 659, which passed March 6, has a mandatory compliance date of Jan. 1, 2027.

"What it does, in brief, is require that cities allow an accessory dwelling unit on every lot or parcel that has a single-family dwelling," Attorney Ryan Simonton previously said of SB659.

By the language of the law, "a municipality shall not adopt a policy, regulation, or ordinance that restricts, prohibits, or otherwise regulates the use of at least one accessory dwelling unit by right on a lot or parcel that contains a single-family dwelling."

Further, the city cannot require additional parking; require ADUs match external design standards with the lone exception of those implemented in historic districts; set requirements for building height, minimum setbacks, minimum lot sizes, or maximum lot coverage more restrictive than for the single-family dwelling; or require water and sewer for the ADU separate from that serving the primary structure.

The law also states a manufactured home may be used as an ADU by right.

In other words, according to one member of city council, the city wanted to allow ADUs where specifically appropriate for Morgantown, but the state delivered "wild west accessory dwelling units" with a one-size fits all approach.

With the deadline for compliance approaching, the matter recently went before the Morgantown Planning Commission for its advisory opinion.

And the majority opinion from the commission is that the city should not enact the law and should use whatever means it has available to push back on what some view as legislative overreach.

"I don't know how to do that other than to claim this is a regulatory taking, but this is an example of an arrogant legislature not paying attention to municipal government and disrespecting municipal government. It's just all wrong," Commissioner Tim Stranko said, calling the matter, "offensive."

Further, Stranko said water and sewer requirements set forth by the West Virginia Public Service Commission state specifically that a service pipe can only service one premises.

"You can't take a water service pipe from somebody's house and run it to a garage for an accessory dwelling unit. It's against the law. It's against the water rules. It's against the sewer rules. So, this whole thing is unlawful," he said, suggesting legal counsel from the Morgantown Utility Board be asked to weigh in.

"I know [city] council's in a jam here, but this is all wrong. Not only is it not compliant with West Virginia law, it's also, again, a terrible imposition on municipal government," he said.

Commissioner Bill Petros said he believes the law runs counter to the city's comprehensive plan, which is the planning commission's primary focus.

"I'm glad you said it first because I was thinking the same thing. And, you know, if city council, someone, doesn't push back on this, who's going to? To me, this is inconsistent with our comprehensive plan, because I think the comprehensive plan emphasizes preservation," Petros said. "Now, I get it, density, but what about the character and integrity of existing residential neighborhoods, particularly single-family neighborhoods? This is inconsistent with that."

Asked why the West Virginia Municipal League did not rally municipalities against the law, Mayor Danielle Trumble, who serves on the planning commission, said she believes the AARP's support for the bill carried a lot of weight.

"My view is it's not even about quality of life in our wards. It's about our ability to say what we want and our local control," Trumble said. "Every session, it's like, 'We're going to take that back. Now we're going to take this back. You don't want data centers? Too bad. ADUs, you don't want those here? Too bad.' It's a constant erosion."

Starting at /week.